second banana
Hero image for the Second Banana New York City landing page. Dark editorial design with a gold rule across the top. Left column reads 'New York' in large serif type with 'Raises A Glass.' in italic gold beneath, followed by the tagline: in 1966, a bartender refused to serve three gay men a drink, and they took it to court; three years later, Stonewall fought back; in 2016 it became a national monument; this city never stopped ordering another round. A peeled banana illustration in gold tones sits centre composition. Right panel shows three statistics: 1966, the Sip-In at Julius', refused a drink, they went to court; 1969, police raid the Stonewall Inn on June 28 and the neighbourhood fights back; 2016, Stonewall becomes the first US national monument to LGBT history. Tag pills along the bottom read: queer, ENM, BDSM, poly, leather, ballroom. Second Banana branding bottom right.

New York City Kink & Fantasy Dating | Find Your Match | Second Banana

SECOND BANANA · NEW YORK, NY

New York Was Refused A Drink. Then It Changed The World. Order What You Want.

On April 21, 1966, three members of the Mattachine Society of New York walked into Julius', a bar in Greenwich Village, with reporters in tow. They said they were gay and asked to be served. The bartender covered their glasses with his hand: "I think it's against the law." They took it to court, and in 1967 judges ruled that same-sex cruising, kissing or touching wasn't indecent on its own. Gay people could legally drink in a bar.

Three years later, on June 28, 1969, police raided the Stonewall Inn on Christopher Street. This time the patrons, and the neighbourhood, fought back, and the resistance went on for days. The Stonewall uprising became the spark for the modern LGBTQ+ rights movement, and Pride marches around the world still mark its anniversary.

On June 24, 2016, Stonewall National Monument was designated: about 7.7 acres covering Christopher Park, the Stonewall Inn and the surrounding streets. It was the first US national monument to honour LGBT history. Two months earlier, on April 21, 2016, 50 years to the day after the Sip-In, Julius' had joined the National Register of Historic Places. New York raises a glass.

Infographic titled 'New York: Last Call, First Round,' with the subtitle 'April 21, 1966: three men walk into a Greenwich Village bar and ask to be served as gay men.' Three cream bar coasters. 1966, the Sip-In: the bartender covers their glasses, 'I think it's against the law.' 1967, the Ruling: courts rule same-sex cruising, kissing or touching isn't indecent on its own; gay people can legally drink in bars. 2016, the Register: Julius' joins the National Register of Historic Places, 50 years to the day. Footer: the Sip-In was staged by members of the Mattachine Society of New York, with reporters along. Source: National Park Service. Second Banana branding.

Ask, Then Order

New Yorkers know exactly what they want and say it fast. That's a good instinct for kink, as long as the other person gets to say what they want too. Put it all on the table before anything starts. That's pre-negotiation, and it's the core of negotiated consent.

Infographic titled 'New York: Set in Bronze.' An illustrative bronze plaque reading Greenwich Village, New York City; Stonewall National Monument; the first US national monument to honour LGBT history. Three figures: June 28, 1969, police raid the inn; June 24, 2016, monument designated; about 7.7 acres of protected ground. Beneath: Christopher Park, the Stonewall Inn, and the surrounding streets and sidewalks. Footer: plaque design is illustrative, not an official marker. Sources: National Park Service; National Geographic. Second Banana branding.

In 1966 they were refused a drink. In 2016 the bar was on the National Register. Keep asking.

→ Post on Second Banana — order what you want.

Every Scene, Every Borough

Leather in Chelsea, ballroom in Harlem and the Bronx, queer nights in Bushwick, rope classes and munches all over: if a kink exists, someone in New York is organising around it. On Second Banana, trans and non-binary members are fully welcome. If you're drawn to power exchange, start with our guide to the psychology of dominance.

New York's ethical non-monogamy scene is huge, but it's still worth reading our honest look at when ENM works and when it doesn't. And in a city where you can bump into your boss on the subway, we take discretion seriously.

Five Boroughs And Beyond

Beyond the Village, New York is bodegas, rooftops, late trains and the endless question of whether to date across a river. Write your post and it reaches Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island and Jersey City. When you need out, Hartford is up I-95 and I-91, and in summer there's always Rehoboth Beach.

Who You'll Find Here

The Second Banana community in New York is as big as the city. The West Village regular who has raised a glass at Julius' more times than they can count. The Brooklyn polycule with a shared Google calendar and a group chat. The finance worker who wants someone else to make every decision on Friday night. The ballroom kid who knows how to perform and how to protect their peace. The newcomer who moved here to finally be themselves.

Tags that index well here: queer, trans-inclusive, ENM, polyamory, leather, BDSM, D/s, rope, fetish, ballroom, switch, kink-experienced, discreet, consent-literate, aftercare-focused. Be specific, and say which borough you're in.

→ Write your first Second Banana post — the next round's on you.

Sign just inside the door of the Stonewall Inn on Christopher Street, recalling the 1969 police raid, photographed on Pride weekend 2016
The "raided premises" sign inside the Stonewall Inn, photographed on Pride weekend 2016, the day after Stonewall National Monument was designated. Photo: Rhododendrites, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Raided Premises

The Stonewall Inn still keeps a sign by the door about the night it was raided. It's a reminder that the freedom to walk into a bar and be yourself was fought for, glass by glass. That's the heart of sexual sovereignty: nobody gets to decide who you love, or how. And whoever you go home with, give them good aftercare.

"I think it's against the law," the bartender said. It wasn't. Never let anyone tell you that wanting is wrong.

Your Second Banana is in that city. They might be in the Village or Bushwick, in Astoria or out in Jersey City, completely open or carefully discreet. They know what they want. Second Banana is where you find each other.

→ Find your Second Banana. New York raises a glass. 🍌

Related Posts